Geoffrey are killed in a biking accident during the 1186 and Constance married (2) Ranulph de- Blundeville, 4 th Earl from Chester, for the step 3 rd March 1188, when you look at the a married relationship set up from the Queen Henry eleven. So it wedding deteriorated and you can Ranulph imprisoned Constance in the 1196. Rebellions was stimulated all over Brittany on her behalf and you can Ranulph put out their in 1198. Back in Brittany, Constance had their own relationship annulled and later into the 1198, she took Guy de Tours given that their particular ‘second’ husband.
Constance passed away aged forty, (perhaps of leprosy, perhaps following childbirth in order to dual girls) on the 5 th September 1201 at the Nantes
Even though this wasn’t good consanguineous relationship however, one of affinity, any earliest-education matchmaking might have rendered marriage anywhere between Constance and you will any one of John’s brothers impossible as opposed to good dispensation –– hence considering the party’s review might have had to come from this new pope himself
The concept that Constance had an affair that have John following loss of Geoffrey and you will just before John’s relationships to Isabella out of Gloucester for the 1189, hence she are mother in order to Joanna is extremely controversial and you will possess provoked far conversation in this genealogical sectors.
One comment regarding good genealogist says you to definitely ‘the diary ‘The new Plantagenet Connection’ keeps had written an ahnentafel regarding E Plantagenet, wife of Henry V11, that provides Joanna’s mom’s identity while the Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess out of Brittany. This is the Constance who was John’s sister-in-laws! As a result of the well-recognized animosity between John and you may Constance along with her very own tries to press their own child Arthur’s passion so far as this new throne of The united kingdomt try alarmed (and we all recognize how disastrously you to proved!), I absolutely select the recommended relationship a small tough to take. Brand new Constance one to record illustrates will not struck me due to the fact to your which John can potentially coerce into sleep.’
‘ A concept who select Joanna’s mother as the Constance doesn’t be the cause of an extremely critical point in cannon laws. That would imply that specific shade of your matter need to certainly attended as cute Passo fundo women hot a result of united states, whether it on it the brand new ask for they, the deliberations, and/or actual dispensation itself. As far as i are alert, nothing of your own type can be obtained.’
By the merely that have sex with John, not to mention impact your a child, Constance might have depending a first-education dating off affinity with all of John’s siblings –– along with John’s aunt Geoffrey
My thoughts for just what it’s well worth, is that got Constance started mom away from Joanna she’d surely keeps introduced their up within her domestic along with her title would be too known as Constance’s other students of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Maid from Brittany, Matilda/Maud regarding Brittany and you may Arthur).
Agatha was given birth to about 1168 from inside the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It’s notorious you to definitely she try a mistress off John and many family members trees offer their, even though solitary, once the mother of Joanna. Most genealogists not are convinced it is just supposition one to the woman is Joanna’s mommy as the zero facts otherwise records can be found to exhibit this.
That provider frequently offered try Sir William Dugdale, on Baronage from The united kingdomt (1675-6). He says their provider to-be Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation for Wales’ (1584). Powell’s efforts are an enlarged release from H Lloyd’s interpretation regarding ‘This new Historie out of Cambria’ by the several th century Saint Caradoc regarding Llancarfan. Another type of resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ by the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 also names Agatha de Ferrers, daughter off Robert de- Ferrers, last Earl from derby, given that Joanna’s mom.
Although she can’t be entirely overlooked just like the an applicant to own mom out of Joanna, undoubtedly there would be some shade out of their own from inside the a beneficial chronicle and other historical resource, if the she got indeed been mom of your partner regarding the fresh Prince away from North Wales.